Forum

> > Off Topic > Will you sacrifice 1 to save 10?
Forums overviewOff Topic overviewLog in to reply

English Will you sacrifice 1 to save 10?

83 replies
Page
To the start Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next To the start

Poll Poll

Will you sacrifice the life of one person to save the lives of ten?

Only registered users are allowed to vote
Yes
61.90% (26)
No
38.10% (16)
42 votes cast

old Re: Will you sacrifice 1 to save 10?

useigor
User Off Offline

Quote
user LazyGuy has written
user useigor has written
But calling them animals is not good. It's can give offense them. Btw there is rule 3.1.

Are they really animals? they are still human calling someone animal its means hatred.

If they were animals then it wasn't offenes same as call monkey "monkey". Comparing human with animal is a offense, because animal < human, usually animals are wild and human can eat some of them. That's the point.

old Re: Will you sacrifice 1 to save 10?

Infinite Rain
Reviewer Off Offline

Quote
user useigor has written
user LazyGuy has written
user useigor has written
But calling them animals is not good. It's can give offense them. Btw there is rule 3.1.

Are they really animals? they are still human calling someone animal its means hatred.

If they were animals then it wasn't offenes same as call monkey "monkey". Comparing human with animal is a offense, because animal < human, usually animals are wild and human can eat some of them. That's the point.

That's his point too, he just want to eat all the moderators!

old Re: Will you sacrifice 1 to save 10?

Matsu-Kiri
User Off Offline

Quote
user Conscience has written
user palomino has written
@user Conscience: No, no one would know of what you have done except you.

Great, then I would not do anything at all. I should not play God over those who I do not know anything about.


Then 10 people would die because of your foolishness. Either way you would not be innocent afterwards so why not just press the button? If you think you can sleep better at night thinking you didn't have anything to do with those 10 people dying because you saved one then you truly are an idiot.

old Re: Will you sacrifice 1 to save 10?

Flacko
User Off Offline

Quote
user Matsu-Kiri has written
user Conscience has written
user palomino has written
@user Conscience: No, no one would know of what you have done except you.

Great, then I would not do anything at all. I should not play God over those who I do not know anything about.


Then 10 people would die because of your foolishness. Either way you would not be innocent afterwards so why not just press the button? If you think you can sleep better at night thinking you didn't have anything to do with those 10 people dying because you saved one then you truly are an idiot.


I'm afraid you are the only true idiot here. Pretending to be right and telling others that they are wrong about a moral question is almost a megalomaniac behavior.

old Re: Will you sacrifice 1 to save 10?

Avo
User Off Offline

Quote
√+1 for what user Assassin moder has written
[...]Yes, because if that 10 saved peoples can save other 100 (each ten) peoples just killing 10 peoples.[...]
I loved that point of view. At the end there would be left only 11 people. The best way to solve problem with overpopulation, btw.

old Re: Will you sacrifice 1 to save 10?

Conscience
User Off Offline

Quote
@user Matsu-Kiri: Why so unfriendly? I have not offended you nor anyone else by giving an answer to a question. I am not going to decide if someone lives or not, it is not my job and I don't believe that I have such right.
Calling me an idiot won't change anything, it just says something about your behavior that you cannot deal with others not sharing your opinion, so don't ever act with such a manor towards a person that has done nothing wrong.

And btw, if I do nothing, 10 people would not die because of me (Because I did absolutely nothing, understand this). 1 person would if I took action, read the OP next time.

Thanks, user Flacko.

old Let it be

Lim Zheng YE
User Off Offline

Quote
Better bite the bullet of the death of 1 person than the moan of 10 persons family
To the start Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next To the start
Log in to replyOff Topic overviewForums overview