English Quality Control

80 replies
Goto Page
To the start Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next To the start
Poll Poll
Should Quality Control be enforced?
Only registered users are allowed to vote
Yes
90.48% (38)
Maybe
4.76% (2)
No
4.76% (2)
42 votes cast
29.11.15 03:19:35 pm
Up
Ortimh
User
Offline Off
@user Starkkz: I can't see the image. I can't see it if it's from Imgur because it's restricted in my country.
I'm awesome ... and I really cookies
29.11.15 03:22:20 pm
Up
Rainoth
Moderator
Offline Off
@user Ortimh: It just shows him editing your account details and selecting user mode. "Reviewer" is one of the possible user mode choices.
29.11.15 03:29:52 pm
Up
Gaios
Security Supporter
Offline Off
I'm good scripter and why only Graphic Designers should review skins? lol. no comments. Are you blind or what? Don't you know how to rate sprite instead of user Pagyra? Those users should be just mature and have big knowegle about these files. I can be reviewer but who care about me.. I already reported many files.

user DC don't forget about FAQ .

EDIT >
edited 1×, last 29.11.15 05:04:36 pm
29.11.15 03:43:29 pm
Up
Rainoth
Moderator
Offline Off
@user Gaios: Why you always doin that shit, man? You become offended by every single thing that is remotely related to you. Sheesh, I was just giving an example, not saying that only people who can evaluate sprites properly are fit to be reviewers and NOBODY ELSE.
Besides, you already got a rank.

// @user DC: By the way, maybe you should hide that "Decline" button if the file has already been approved. I mean, why keep it if we know it's okay already?
29.11.15 03:48:02 pm
Up
DC
Admin
Offline Off
@user Rainoth: I'm developing in the live environment like a (very foolish) boss Bear with me. It's work in progress and it makes no sense to comment it until it's done. I'll let you guys know when it's finished.

It makes sense to allow to decline already approved files. Keep in mind that files can always be edited - also to the worse. This should (hopefully) be an uncommon scenario but it should be possible to handle it anyway.
www.UnrealSoftware.de | www.CS2D.com | www.CarnageContest.com | Use the forum & avoid PMs!
29.11.15 04:02:59 pm
Up
Fraizeraust
Moderator
Offline Off
There is a problem though. Every single file on File Archive is unreviewed not just new uploads. I thought the only new uploads are unreviewed but I think the very old files can be ignored (let them unreviewed as they are), no?
Aside from this, you gotta have to translate the review message in German language on German section part of File Archive. Just as a reminder note.

// And when everything is done successfully and supposed to work as it should be, I'll update (is just a minor one) the US.de article on Wiki with new info regard this later.
29.11.15 04:11:28 pm
Up
VADemon
User
Offline Off
@user DC: If only your employer knew what you're doing here

@user Gaios: Letsa hope reviewers will be reasonable and not review stuff they are bad in. You and me? Lua scripts. We have an idea on what's going on there. Though we'll be able to recognize a total bullshitty map/sprite upload, for that matter.
29.11.15 04:34:03 pm
Up
DC
Admin
Offline Off
@user Fraizeraust: No, I want to take this as an opportunity to "re-review" all files here. The default decline messages are already translated depending on the selected website language. When you write custom decline messages you should stick to the language of the file archive section the file is in of course.
www.UnrealSoftware.de | www.CS2D.com | www.CarnageContest.com | Use the forum & avoid PMs!
29.11.15 04:35:54 pm
Up
Yates
Reviewer
Offline Off
@user DC: What about files such as Tibia? These are quite bugged yet bug fixes are uploaded everywhere. Do these files get approved? And if not - Weiwen has not been online for a very long time. He won't be fixing anything any time soon
29.11.15 04:50:18 pm
Up
Gaios
Security Supporter
Offline Off
user VADemon has written:
@user Gaios: Letsa hope reviewers will be reasonable and not review stuff they are bad in. You and me? Lua scripts. We have an idea on what's going on there. Though we'll be able to recognize a total bullshitty map/sprite upload, for that matter.

I know that but user Rainoth is looking for something to make make fu*k up. And no, don't reply here Rainoth, I don't answer on bullshit. Stop draw some conclusions and write nonsense.
Rainoth: "Hey! You already got a rank, you can't get next." Perfect. I said that "I can" and not "I must".
Spoiler >
edited 1×, last 29.11.15 04:56:58 pm
29.11.15 04:56:19 pm
Up
Infinite Rain
Reviewer
Offline Off
@user Gaios:
Not to offend or anything but you're acting really immature right now. user Rainoth made a valid point. Stop getting offended by everything, that doesn't make you look any smarter.
A thousand may fall at your side, ten thousand at your right hand, but it will not come near you. You will only look with your eyes and see the recompense of the wicked. - Psalm 91:7-8 ESV
29.11.15 04:59:54 pm
Up
Gaios
Security Supporter
Offline Off
@user Infinite Rain: I don't agree. For me only users with big knowledge can moderate File Archive, no graphers or scripters. This is why I don't agree. You can select users that are pro scipters or anything but this isn't the reason.

As I said, no more answers from me, you go off-topic then.
29.11.15 05:04:37 pm
Up
DC
Admin
Offline Off
@user Yates: Common sense please.

Of course very popular files should not be declined even if they contain bugs. Bugs are not a reason at all to remove files.

And files fixing bugs of popular scripts because the actual author is inactive shouldn't be removed either I guess. Unless there are good reasons to do so.

There is no technical reason to get rid of any files. There is more than enough space for all the stuff and a lot more. So stuff should only be removed if it really is super useless crap that NOBODY wants.

Edit:
Almost finished. Can someone please decline (NOT REMOVE!) this file:
http://www.unrealsoftware.de/files_show.php?file=16735

Edit²:
Thanks for declining user Rainoth
Seems to work fine. I'll add the overview page for unreviewed files etc. tomorrow or later and I'll also create a thread about choosing some reviewer after doing this. This is all was more work than expected but I'm sure it's worth it.

btw: When you have declined files you'll see an annoying yellow box which asks you to do something. When it's just one file it will bring you to the file directly, when it's multiple files you will be led to the list of your own files in your profile.

To all moderators: You are free to accept/decline files already if you want to.
edited 3×, last 29.11.15 06:59:38 pm
www.UnrealSoftware.de | www.CS2D.com | www.CarnageContest.com | Use the forum & avoid PMs!
29.11.15 07:02:19 pm
Up
Rainoth
Moderator
Offline Off
IMG:https://sc-cdn.scaleengine.net/i/696563ca2a616573f1e36684c3a12dd9.png

See? This is why I suggested to remove the cooldown for moderators and admins

So the file you referred to will be deleted in how long? 1 day? a week? month?
29.11.15 07:08:13 pm
Up
DC
Admin
Offline Off
It won't be removed. I didn't implement the automatic removal thing yet. I want to test the feature a bit more first.

It will be rather high when I add it because there is no real reason to keep it short. The files are hidden anyway from the normal lists in the file archive. So at least 1 month.
www.UnrealSoftware.de | www.CS2D.com | www.CarnageContest.com | Use the forum & avoid PMs!
29.11.15 07:18:16 pm
Up
Rainoth
Moderator
Offline Off
Oh, just a little note. The window for declining is bigger than the textboxes and we're "declining" files, not "delincing" them
29.11.15 07:27:05 pm
Up
DC
Admin
Offline Off
Not sure what you mean with the size stuff. It's "normal" that there is some white space (also for the scrollbar) in the popup window. I don't think it's an issue.

I fixed the typo. Thanks
www.UnrealSoftware.de | www.CS2D.com | www.CarnageContest.com | Use the forum & avoid PMs!
29.11.15 07:32:34 pm
Up
VADemon
User
Offline Off
The notification box should be on top of the description if the file was declined. Since some are too stupid to use the search box, they would also easily oversee the DECLINED box if it'll not give them eye-AIDS straight away.
29.11.15 09:42:59 pm
Up
secritek
User
Offline Off
How about also including something like Approved User for the people who are part of the community for long and have experience with the skin section so their files will be automatically approved after uploading. It would make the job for the moderators easier by removing some additional work off their shoulders and save some of their time?
IMG:http://i.imgur.com/0kd8i.png
29.11.15 10:19:21 pm
Up
Pseudon
User
Offline Off
The problem is not about the new files being uploaded since they are being uploaded at a slow rate, but with the files which have been already uploaded over the time.
*Empty*
To the start Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next To the start