English Minecraft VS Stranded

59 replies
Goto Page
To the start Previous 1 2 3 Next To the start
Poll Poll
Whats better?
Only registered users are allowed to vote
Minecraft
58.52% (79)
Stranded
41.48% (56)
135 votes cast
08.05.11 12:23:52 pm
Up
Quake-Ranger
User
Offline Off
If you compare Minecraft with Stranded, then you should compare Stranded with the free (classic) version of Minecraft.
IMG:http://www.keygenmusic.net/gfx/BashBrain_bar2.png
08.05.11 12:47:01 pm
Up
Bowlinghead
User
Offline Off
@ Assasin Moder:
But it's not realistic that you get Hurt if you don't sleep enough!
Share time limited free games here
08.05.11 12:47:32 pm
Up
DC
Admin
Offline Off
user Bowlinghead has written:
Minecraft!
Stranded is a survival game but it's not realistic! With weapons and buildings...
Minecraft dont trie to be a realistiv game!

Stranded doesn't try to be realistic either. there are raptors and teleports! do you really think that I tried to make it as realistic as possible? hilarious!

about the "random" thing and "everything new": maybe you didn't note that Stranded has randomly generated maps as well. it actually has an scripted adventure mode (which Minecraft doesn't have) AND randomly generated maps.

I really like the great freedom in Minecraft and the possibility to build like everything with those cubes. I also love how it is 100% about gameplay and doesn't really care too much about the graphics.
edited 1×, last 08.05.11 12:49:31 pm
www.UnrealSoftware.de | www.CS2D.com | www.CarnageContest.com | Use the forum & avoid PMs!
08.05.11 12:49:27 pm
Up
DannyDeth
User
Offline Off
For me, I find Mine craft a real time-hogger, but I still love my SII. I can't really decide out of the two, though. Like DC said, the freedom with the blocks is amazing in Minecraft.
08.05.11 12:53:13 pm
Up
ez-crow
User
Offline Off
Minecraft. SII is awesome too, but minecraft has an endless world. And 8bit is coool.
08.05.11 01:02:40 pm
Up
Alistaire
User
Offline Off
Minecraft TOTALLY. It has much larger worlds, much more items and you can make much more things. In stranded you cant build hogwarts or middle earth, beat that!
IMG:http://i.imgur.com/5zhwOTP.png
08.05.11 01:07:22 pm
Up
siD
User
Offline Off
minecraft is just block a pone block well stranded you can script and do stuff with out a hammer

stranded√
minecraft×
08.05.11 01:13:39 pm
Up
Quake-Ranger
User
Offline Off
Why do you compare Stranded with the Survival part of Minecraft? Stranded is free and has a different goal: Survive and escape from the island. Minecraft Surivalmode costs money and you just build your house up or whatever.
IMG:http://www.keygenmusic.net/gfx/BashBrain_bar2.png
08.05.11 01:15:03 pm
Up
Yates
Reviewer
Offline Off
Don't you get it? To create something is fun. It just is, everyone loves it.
08.05.11 01:20:24 pm
Up
Quake-Ranger
User
Offline Off
user Yates has written:
Don't you get it? To create something is fun. It just is, everyone loves it.

Have you read my previous posts?
Its unfair to compare a freeware game which is almost 3 years old with an updating commercial game which has a completely different goal.
IMG:http://www.keygenmusic.net/gfx/BashBrain_bar2.png
08.05.11 01:26:45 pm
Up
Bowlinghead
User
Offline Off
@ DC:
Yes the Story Mod in Stranded is good, but what I sometimes miss are the Hands in Stranded! You can't see what tool you use at the moment except you look in the right-down corner!
I also think that the Crafting System in Minecraft is better, because (At German: Was heist übersichtlich?) you have more fantasy! For example an axt is in Stranded a Stone+wood. In Minecraft it's
Spoiler >

0= Nothing
1= Wood/Stone/Iron/Gold/Diamant
2= stock

----------
PS: Stranded is close at the realistic!
Minecraft is just awesome because it has Zombies, Creepers, ... And in Minecraft you can build almost everthing...
Aircraft
House
Monster killer

But Stranded is free :D.
Stranded is better than the Classic-Minecraft (Free minecraft) but not better than the real Minecraft.
Share time limited free games here
08.05.11 04:45:35 pm
Up
Mechanolith
User
Offline Off
Do you now when you loves a game like: Wow, i was searching for one like this!

That's exactly what happened to me and Minecraft.
Btw, having 10fps in Minecraft made me laugh, you don't need a f**king awesome PC to play Minecraft, it's just a normal PC, and really, Stranded II isn't fun to me and it lags more than Minecraft.
The Minecraft graphics aren't 8-bit and it isn't hard to notice that, the sounds aswell, both are 32-bit and in a very good quality, Notch made Minecraft with this graphics because he want, it's not because he couldn't make better.
Minecraft as @DC say'd, has an awesome freedom and gameplay, building things with blocks and really don't caring about the graphic (which i really like, because i love PixelArt) makes Minecraft the best game for me.
08.05.11 05:07:51 pm
Up
Danikah
User
Offline Off
Which is better?
Terraria
:trollface:
08.05.11 05:20:27 pm
Up
Bowlinghead
User
Offline Off
user Mechanolith has written:
Do you now when you loves a game like: Wow, i was searching for one like this!

That's exactly what happened to me and Minecraft.
Btw, having 10fps in Minecraft made me laugh, you don't need a f**king awesome PC to play Minecraft, it's just a normal PC, and really, Stranded II isn't fun to me and it lags more than Minecraft.
The Minecraft graphics aren't 8-bit and it isn't hard to notice that, the sounds aswell, both are 32-bit and in a very good quality, Notch made Minecraft with this graphics because he want, it's not because he couldn't make better.
Minecraft as @DC say'd, has an awesome freedom and gameplay, building things with blocks and really don't caring about the graphic (which i really like, because i love PixelArt) makes Minecraft the best game for me.



Exept this I had too!
I look in Youtube "New Game" than I found Minesweeper (Windows Game) than I saw a Minecraft Let's play!
After that my whole life has changed!
Now, if I play other Games, I get headache because nothing is like Minecraft
Share time limited free games here
08.05.11 05:36:12 pm
Up
Bloodshot
User
Offline Off
user Medeiros has written:
Why isn't a general thread about Minecraft itself here?
I'm tired of seeing every new post about Minecraft...


I made one a long time ago before Minecraft was popular, (April) and even though I love the game, I agree completely. This forum is about the games of Unreal Software, and the Off-Topic subforum should have one thread per topic/game, not one thread per topic per game. Unless DC wants to create a subforum dedicated to Minecraft, I think we should keep it as organized as possible.
Old thread BTW
It is better to fail and then succeed than to succeed in the first place IMG:http://i420.photobucket.com/albums/pp281/L31ch3/Userbars/Strandedgamerub.png
08.05.11 07:37:43 pm
Up
Kurumi
User
Offline Off
DC sorry for competing your game with other.
Uhm... Hello
08.05.11 07:55:44 pm
Up
Rocik
User
Offline Off
Minecraft and Stranded are two different games. It's like compare TF2 and CS or GTA and Mafia...
Stranded is survival game, minecraft is sandbox. Survival in minecraft is only one of the additives.
I like much more Minecraft of course, because there is more things to do than Stranded. I hope Stranded III beat Minecraft ;), it's not hard as survival game.
08.05.11 08:17:05 pm
Up
pupp3tStudios
User
Offline Off
Hands down : Stranded II. I enjoy modding that game.
So, combine the possibilities of Minecraft and the stuff of Stranded II (too many to list), and you got an AWESOME game right there.
Don't think that will be done for a long while.
09.05.11 05:24:58 am
Up
PyKemis
User
Offline Off
MC Crafting
Stranded II Survival

That's not a lot of compare since in stranded I die within 3 minutes into the game, where as in MC I die within 5 minutes into the game.
09.05.11 06:37:55 am
Up
ump5master
User
Offline Off
I like stranded more, because it has got more surival feeling. For example, in MC you don't have to eat and the world is out of blocks.
MC is more creative, but anyhow, Stranded is favourite game!
usmp5master
To the start Previous 1 2 3 Next To the start