English minecraft or sII?

80 replies
Goto Page
To the start Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next To the start
Poll Poll
MC or SII
Only registered users are allowed to vote
minecraft
62.37% (58)
stranded II
37.63% (35)
93 votes cast
02.01.12 03:53:45 am
Up
PyKemis
User
Offline Off
When gameplay are at the same we look at the graphics...
Edit: the game play isn't the same...however it's kinda the same genre

Would you want to play a game with awesome game with poor graphics or a game with awesome game play and awesome graphics?

It's easier to die in sII though no doubt.
02.01.12 04:47:42 am
Up
Geez
GAME BANNED
Offline Off
@Textual Context
Yes, I wanna play awesome game with awesome game with poor graphics

However, how an awesome game can have awesome game with poor graphics inside? Mini-game with poor graphics?

nvm, it's awesome anyway
02.01.12 01:04:24 pm
Up
Frost321
User
Offline Off
user EpicCrisis has written:
I guess both are good.

Minecraft :
∗ Build all the shit you want in this world.
∗ Enemies are awesome.
∗ World generator seed (Can generate really awesome mountains and ravines).
∗ Creative crafting.
° No objective (Bored after a week of playing).
° Graphics?
° Hard to understand how to use a mod.
° Lag most of the time playing it.

Stranded :
∗ Adventure game with objective to get out of an island.
∗ Free game is always good.
∗ Real survival with puzzles on creating tools.
∗ Able to create maps you want.
° Limited terrain. (Can't travel from the island to find another island).
° Building is too boring. (Right click, right click, right click, right click, right click, right click, right click).
° Limited on what you can build.
° Graphics too?

That's all I know.


     
If you cant come up with sensible reasons, then shut up.

Quote:
No objective (Bored after a week of playing).


Stranded two doesn't have objectives either. Only campaign that is 4 hours long.

Quote:
° Graphics?


Texture packs are always an alternative. Some of them have better graphic, then crysis.

Quote:
° Hard to understand how to use a mod.


Then you must be pretty dumb. IQ - TEQ

Quote:
° Lag most of the time playing it.


Minimal requirements for minecraft are

Cpu : Pentium 4 2.4GHz

RAM: 1gb

HDD space: 1gb

Direct X : 9

This is nothing compared to todays computers.
If your pc didn't met minimum requirements, it is nothing more then piece of scrap looted from junkyard.


Main reason why stranded 2 has some votes here is because it is made on site where most of the players play stranded 2. They didnt play or cant afford minecraft.

Now the funny part "Me like strand3d 2 iz free, minecraft iz not freeee. Game suckz ass"
edited 1×, last 02.01.12 01:16:40 pm
02.01.12 01:14:32 pm
Up
Corvallis5
User
Offline Off
you obviously dont know anything about being polite
geez, its not like you post was good either, you just insulted other peoples posts
STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STR
02.01.12 01:23:32 pm
Up
Frost321
User
Offline Off
user Corvallis5 has written:
you obviously dont know anything about being polite
geez, its not like you post was good either, you just insulted other peoples posts


Polite ? How can i be polite while reading such a bullshit. My brain will turn into taco. Most of the people saying that minecraft sucks, are jealous that they cant afford it or play it, and other half is close to fanboys.

If it sucks then why the hell i cant see some sensible reasons, why ?

This thread is like CS2D vs CS original. CS2D is awesome because its free. That is not reason why to hate. If you are poor then say it straight and don't say it sucks.
02.01.12 01:39:43 pm
Up
Corvallis5
User
Offline Off
i dont think anybody in this thread can't afford Mindcraft
but Mindcraft is definitely not worth $20.

First of all the graphics are horrible (even compared to S2).

Then it's just to blocky, all you do is gather and place blocks to build things, and there's no adventure mod and not as many mods (and the ones that exist arent too good and only modify a couple of things)
STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STR
02.01.12 02:01:50 pm
Up
Battlepaw
User
Offline Off
Well to be honest, minecraft has improved greatly over the years. The newer version of survival mode is interesting, and I've run some of the more advanced mods such as one that turns it into a large, civilization-like mode where you provide cities with resources and watch the citizens actually build the buildings and stuff.

People are getting better and better at modding that game. I remember what it was like years ago and its come a long way. The online "Bukkit" scripts for multiplayer is eliminating most of the greifing that goes on and opening up whole new ways of playing including multiple-world servers connected by many different methods and script based gameplay.

I'm a big fan of "Classic" games and graphics aren't really that important to me, just gameplay and flexibility.
02.01.12 02:08:30 pm
Up
VAU
User
Offline Off
Hmm, i like both games, but more minecraft...
Youre more free, can play with your friends, etc...
02.01.12 08:47:55 pm
Up
Frost321
User
Offline Off
user Corvallis5 has written:
i dont think anybody in this thread can't afford Mindcraft
but Mindcraft is definitely not worth $20.

First of all the graphics are horrible (even compared to S2).

Then it's just to blocky, all you do is gather and place blocks to build things, and there's no adventure mod and not as many mods (and the ones that exist arent too good and only modify a couple of things)


you are obviously stupid. You didnt play minecraft. Dont say you did because if you would then you would know that texture packs are soltion for this problem. Graphic is not all and i like it blocky.

Only retard would rate game without playing it.
02.01.12 08:52:08 pm
Up
Mechanolith
User
Offline Off
user Corvallis5 has written:
i dont think anybody in this thread can't afford Mindcraft
but Mindcraft is definitely not worth $20.

Never heard of Mindcraft, is it about building neurons and stuff?

user Corvallis5 has written:
First of all the graphics are horrible (even compared to S2).

Better intentionally blocky than simple not detailed 3d models.

user Corvallis5 has written:
Then it's just to blocky, all you do is gather and place blocks to build things, and there's no adventure mod and not as many mods (and the ones that exist arent too good and only modify a couple of things)

In Stranded all you do is surviving, punching lions and being restricted to a finite medium island.
In minecraft there is lots of mods that completely change the gameplay, but you don't look smart enough to find them.
02.01.12 09:03:37 pm
Up
Seekay
Reviewer
Offline Off
Compare a sandbox-game with a survival-adventure-game.

Awesome.
I know a good slipgate to shove you in
02.01.12 09:14:15 pm
Up
Rocik
User
Offline Off
Graphic is • NOT • a textures quality!
03.01.12 02:09:22 am
Up
Smilesoldier
User
Offline Off
user Corvallis5 has written:
i dont think anybody in this thread can't afford Mindcraft
but Mindcraft is definitely not worth $20.

First of all the graphics are horrible (even compared to S2).

Then it's just to blocky, all you do is gather and place blocks to build things, and there's no adventure mod and not as many mods (and the ones that exist arent too good and only modify a couple of things)

There's much more to Minecraft than gathering and placing blocks. You can explore the Nether, mine, craft stuff, create potions, enchant items, and explore the overworld.
No adventure mod?
Minecraft doesn't need an adventure mod...
Mods only modify a couple of things?
Search for the Aether Mod.
Also, graphics don't make a game.
03.01.12 03:43:35 am
Up
PyKemis
User
Offline Off
Well you can argue a reason is because mc is massively multiplayer while s2 is only single player.
04.01.12 05:29:12 pm
Up
Jawohl
User
Offline Off
user Smilesoldier has written:
user Corvallis5 has written:
i dont think anybody in this thread can't afford Mindcraft
but Mindcraft is definitely not worth $20.

First of all the graphics are horrible (even compared to S2).

Then it's just to blocky, all you do is gather and place blocks to build things, and there's no adventure mod and not as many mods (and the ones that exist arent too good and only modify a couple of things)

There's much more to Minecraft than gathering and placing blocks. You can explore the Nether, mine, craft stuff, create potions, enchant items, and explore the overworld.
No adventure mod?
Minecraft doesn't need an adventure mod...
Mods only modify a couple of things?
Search for the Aether Mod.
Also, graphics don't make a game.


agreed 100% minecraft has unlimited worlds, awsome mods, more then 9 million downloads on planetminecraft (just an example of minecraft credits)
05.01.12 04:26:12 am
Up
Corvallis5
User
Offline Off
In Stranded all you do is surviving, punching lions and being restricted to a finite medium island.
In minecraft there is lots of mods that completely change the gameplay, but you don't look smart enough to find them.

and your calling me dumb?
I recall you saying that you couldn't survive in S2 becuase you couldn't figure out how to get water,

okay maybe I was a little too harsh on MC it is not that bad of a game
STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STRANDED III STR
05.01.12 06:13:54 am
Up
Jawohl
User
Offline Off
well, of majority, minecraft... funny thing is... this is SII's webpage, but still lost... dont get e wrong SII was a good game... but im bored of it nowdays... theres just so many cool thing one may do in minecraft...

anyways... the voting wont stop until the people do...
when this thread goes dead... only then do we know they won
edited 1×, last 07.01.12 03:50:29 pm
04.02.12 08:02:47 pm
Up
AssassinLV
User
Offline Off
I played both games, MC somewhere is quite inlogical (S2 is quite inlogical as good.)

There is always a choose of pirate of MC, (I played for free) (search for: the pirate bay, DOT!!!, net)

Both games have TOTTALY OTHER ENGINE! In S2 trees falls with all the leaves, in MC you can't make it to fall in such a way, you can make that logs can fall, if under it has no objects, BUT leaves WILL fly into the air as long as there will be a log somewhere close to it, OR disapear.

You can make a mod in S2, to add the feutures from MC, (I'm thining about it all the time, but I am not a good scripter, and I don't know about modeling much as good, so I think, I will simply think about the mod like that, but not to start the job ).
04.02.12 08:56:39 pm
Up
Doctard
User
Offline Off
Im not trying to say S2 is bad but Minecraft is better to me
IMG:http://img269.imageshack.us/img269/8625/32068.gif
IMG:http://img847.imageshack.us/img847/5271/45142.gif
|\ ~|\ ~|\~~~\o/~~~~~~~
To the start Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next To the start